It began at Ghanzi Primary Hospital where I rounded, mentored, and then at 1530 hit the road for the 7hr journey back to Gabs. About 2hrs into the drive, one where I was in a hurry as you do better in the light where the animals are easily seen and avoided, I encountered a vehicle half out into the road, stalled and obviously broken down. I pulled up and asked how things were. “Not fine, not OK”
I hopped out and quickly diagnosed the car with a metal shavings for a gear box. The six people that the car had been transporting were in the classic group, speaking and gesticulating loudly. I asked if anyone wanted a ride, no response.
As I started the car they all noticed I was leaving and ran to the rig demanding a ride. I stated that I could take three followed by more lengthy discussion. Again I started the car, discussion ceased, and in piled three Batswana, followed again with loud discussion, smiles and laughter. We exchanged names and what it was we did. The woman in the front was a maid, one of the men in the back was a teacher, the other a brick layer. And then it started.
“I wouldn’t need to ride if the government paid better” she said. This coming from a Motswana that could avail herself of a free or near free education up through university, free health care, underwritten costs for food, and more. She was joined by all the others. I must admit that my response was less than charitable.
“Tell me what your dream is in the next five years.” This was followed by a lot of “I wants” and laughter. It then occurred to me that laughter is so much a part of the culture that not only did it cement a relationship, deflect confrontation in a relationship, but it also deferred accountability. “How will you get from here to a “huge house and a good car”” I asked. Silence, followed by more sentences that contained “the government”. I asked “who owns your life?” Again silence, laughter, no response. "How many of you have children?" Two had a single child. "Really, how old?” Silence, neither the woman nor one of the guys could answer as they were both parents in abstentia. “Why are you leaving your child and going on “vacation” without him/here?” Silence. I had had it, and regrettably erupted.
“This is so emblematic of this country, of any country with an underclass. Who here has graduated from secondary school?” The woman hadn’t with any apparent reason other than ambivalence. “OK, that makes you both unfortunate and stupid. You’re telling me that you couldn’t walk to school for a free education? Was there a problem?” She teared up and I backed off, regretting my outburst of righteousness. The others were leaning forward in the seat and the gauntlet was thrown down. Everything was someone else’s fault and but for that they’re lives would be successful, right up through parenthood. I said to try not using the word “government” for the next five minutes. Silence again. I became even more paternal.
“Let me see if I get this right; you have free education, free health care, food at underwritten cost (that to be fair is stored dry as there often is no electricity for refrigeration), 160 days of paid time if laid off, and the like.”
Others have declared that this is beginning to resemble a “nanny state”. Maybe. The Scandinavians are close but why do they seem more successful? Are we in an adolescent period that necessitates this as a natural progression to due process and prosperity for all here? I admit it is easy to say when I come from relative privilege, but "why isn’t there any entrepreneurial drive?Who owns the grocery stores?” “The Indians.” “The dry goods stores?” “The Chinese and the Indians.” ‘The auto dealerships?” “The Indians”. The contractors?” “The Chinese”, and again to be fair the bids are low-balled courtesy of the Chinese government.“Why not the Batswana?”
All the stops were off and that voice in my head was ignored. “Why not build the bricks and sell them, not build with them, have an agency for maids, get a free PhD.?” Laughter.
“What is funny, why laugh?” “We love to laugh.” “I get that, but do you have an answer?” “All looked to the floor, a sign of humility here. Jeez I was righteous and was having no effect. Damn I’d blown it. But because of the venting I felt better. I know stupid, really stupid and not at all charitable. We sat in silence.
The only way things could have been more awkward was if the dark road was smokey from desert fires set by someone out there. We crept. Soon they were again talking and one translated. “We think you have a point, Rra.” “I don’t want to be right. I would like you to think and ask yourselves some important questions beginning with: If I’m here, headed on vacation, where is my child?” “Am I truly ready to parent?” “Exactly who is in my sexual network? These are easy and necessary questions with no easy answers and in a country with an HIV prevalence of 40% in your age group YOU need to be accountable to yourself and answer it”
As I write this I’m not proud of it but for the sake of transparency, something for which I dedicated this blog in the beginning, there it is. I got home with ambivalent feelings and then recalled how fortunate I was to have spent time in the remote bush.